Debate on mandatory drug testing

arguments against drug testing in schools

Schools do this because if they advise students' beforehand about a drug test date, casual drug users can plan accordingly by choosing to avoid drugs a few weeks leading up to the test, which means that schools cannot "catch" students that use drugs. The new ruling opened the way for much wider testing of students.

Should middle school students be drug tested

But many districts decided the legal parameters of testing were so uncertain that they should await further guidance before adopting a plan. And when they do, they have such symptoms that we do not need random tests to tell that they are on drugs. Some sacrifice of human rights is necessary to tackle the drug problem. From Glen Cove, N. Researchers focused primarily on students who participated in activities that would make them subject to the random drug testing, but also examined the impacts on other students. Draconian, Big Brother-style tactics of random drug testing will only provoke resentment and encourage students to break the law. Refutations: 1. At the recent meeting there was a general feeling that the task force was getting nowhere. Therefore, new methods are needed. Department of Education's Office of Safe and Drug Free Schools to implement mandatory-random drug testing programs in their 36 high schools.

Students who do not break the law by taking drugs have nothing to fear. Of the students subject to drug testing, 34 percent reported that they "definitely will" or "probably will" use substances in the next 12 months, compared with And if the specimen is adulterated, the test will not be able to detect drugs.

Should athletes be drug tested

The fact of the matter is, even though the Fourth Amendment to the Constitution says that Americans have the right to privacy, both teachers and students essentially waive this right at school for a variety of different reasons. False sense of security Some parents warn that the results of drug tests are in fact so untrustworthy that they fear others will actually gain a false sense of security from knowing their schools test. Recently, a survey by the local paper found the town evenly split on the issue. The fact is its not fair, and completely unconstitutional. Methamphetamine hydrochloride or "shabu" and marijuana are the illegal drugs preferred by one in every 29 Filipinos aged 10 to 44 years. Throughout his drug use, Kirkwood says her son was being randomly tested to little avail. You need to have the local community work through the issue, talking to parents and kids and the people who do drug treatment. And when they do, they have such symptoms that we do not need random tests to tell that they are on drugs. The purpose of random drug testing is not so much to catch offenders but to prevent all students fro Students have the right to privacy. Anti-drug measures should be fully compliant with international and constitutional standards upholding, promoting, and protecting the rights of the child. Although young people have enough information about drugs, they carry on ruining their health. But now, here and in small towns across the nation, drug testing has become a hot issue.

Extracurricular activities and privileges are usually revoked. Instead, students should be taught about the effects of drugs, and what to do to best handle the situation responsibly and safely if the opportunity arises.

The list goes on and on.

Drug testing in schools statistics

Warrant: Students should not be forced to undergo drug testing to participate in sport or other activities. Brad Bartelmay, a local pastor. Once teenagers are using drugs, it is much harder for them to break their addiction. Current measu Some sacrifice of human rights is necessary to tackle the drug problem. Rather than resolving the question, it seems, the court's decision has touched off a new round of passionate debate. While many people who support drug testing in schools would say it helps make school a safe, drug-free environment and helps detect early drug-use in students thereby creating room for the student to seek help, this rarely happens. Before the Supreme Court's decision, about 5 percent of the nation's public school districts conducted drug tests of student athletes -- a practice that the court upheld in Draconian, Big Brother-style tactics of random drug testing will only provoke resentment and encourage students to break the law. It's not the school's business what the student does outside of school.
Rated 10/10 based on 57 review
Download
Should drug testing be mandatory?